|
Clarks Law
|
|
|
|
[1][ISMAP]-[2][Home]
|
|
[3]
|
|
### GUIDE ### [4][Index] [5][Previous] [6][Next]
|
|
|
|
_Contents:_ [7]Back Cover - [8]Synopsis - [9]Questions - [10]Analysis
|
|
- [11]Notes - [12]Author
|
|
|
|
_________________________________________________________________
|
|
|
|
_Written by Jim Mortimore_
|
|
Release date: January 10, 1996
|
|
ISBN: 0440-22229-X
|
|
Setting: Late 2259, between [13]"Comes the Inquisitor" and [14]"The
|
|
Fall of Night"
|
|
|
|
Sheridan is torn between duty and defiance when he's ordered to
|
|
execute an innocent alien.
|
|
|
|
_________________________________________________________________
|
|
|
|
Back Cover
|
|
|
|
Death Before Dishonor
|
|
|
|
The Tuchanq, a newly discovered humanoid species, can be an important
|
|
ally for the Earth Alliance commanded by President Clark. So Captain
|
|
John Sheridan welcomes their ambassadors to babylon 5, not knowing
|
|
that among them is D'arc - a mass murderer on the run hoping to escape
|
|
into the unsuspecting worlds of the galaxy....
|
|
|
|
Clark's Law
|
|
|
|
But the unforgiving rules of space have a different fate in store for
|
|
D'arc. A terrifying accident wipes away D'arc's identity and his
|
|
evil... leaving behind a loving, innocent being with a child's mind -
|
|
a being that must die because President Clark, a leader with his own
|
|
secret agenda, orders his immediate execution. Now, as Babylon 5
|
|
physician Dr. Stephen Franklin begs Sheridan to defy Clark's law, the
|
|
captain faces the greatest test of his command - and a far greater
|
|
test of his manhood, which may end his career in shame or become a
|
|
shining reminder of what being human truly means....
|
|
|
|
Synopsis
|
|
|
|
Prologue: Lies
|
|
|
|
"Earth: First Lie": Opening in November of 2242, we see the Captain of
|
|
the Earth vessel which fired on the Minbari lie to the president and
|
|
then Vice President Santiago about who fired first. Captaion Ferdinand
|
|
claims it is the Minbari who fired first.
|
|
|
|
"Earth: Second Lie": The scene opens on now President Clark in October
|
|
of 2258 (See [15]Notes.) Clark has been plotting to reinstate the
|
|
death penalty to regain popularity among humans by maintaining control
|
|
and re-initiating capital punishment. Clark's internal thoughts also
|
|
turn to the problems with Earth's colonies without which Earth could
|
|
not survive. The senate is tied on the vote about re-instating capital
|
|
punishment. Clark lies when the speaker of the senate asks if it will
|
|
be equally applied to both humans and aliens. Answering yes, the
|
|
speaker of the senate agrees to pass the law.
|
|
|
|
"Tuchanq: First Lie": The scene is inside a Narn battle cruiser as
|
|
G'Kar drops Centauri plasma generators on Tuchanq. After a few days
|
|
G'Kar lands the Narn cruiser offering the Tuchanq assistance in
|
|
recovering from the devestation caused by the "Centauri."
|
|
|
|
"Tuchanq: Second Lie": October 2259, we see D'Arc of the Tuchanq
|
|
killing the last of the Narn on Tuchanq and then boarding a Narn
|
|
cruiser to head for Babylon 5 in search of assistance. Tuchanq has
|
|
suffered tremendous environmental damage from years of Narn
|
|
enslavement.
|
|
|
|
Part One: Among Shadows (December 12, 2259, Day)
|
|
|
|
The story opens on Sheridan eating breakfast and trying to cope with
|
|
the mounds of paperwork that he needs to deeal with as well as his own
|
|
discomfort in his role as commander of Babylon 5. His mind turns the
|
|
phrase "If you go to Z'ha'dum you will die" over and over again as he
|
|
contemplates life. (See In the Shadow of Z'ha'dum)
|
|
|
|
Ivanova interupts his inner turmoil in order to be briefed on the
|
|
arrival of the Tuchanq delegation. She remarks on the unusual fact
|
|
that they are quadrapeds and after some jokes about the paper horizon
|
|
and stations vanishing, he leaves her in charge of the matter. The
|
|
problem for the Tuchanq is that there world's ecosystem has been
|
|
destroyed by the Narn occupation.
|
|
|
|
"The Corps is your friend. Trust the Corps" Ivanova is still plagued
|
|
with thoughts about her friendship with Talia and hears her whispered
|
|
words, more than just the touch of bodies, the touch of minds. After
|
|
shaking herself awake from her nap, she struggles to gain inner peace
|
|
as the core shuttle heads towards arrivals. The inner struggle relates
|
|
to her continued denial of her telepathic abilities and the need to
|
|
hide it to avoid the Psi Cops.
|
|
|
|
Arriving in the customs area, things were already turning ugly. The
|
|
Tuchanq were engaged in a bizzare ritual involving leaving blood on
|
|
the floor of the arrival area. G'Kar had helped program a translator
|
|
for Ivanova, but she turned out not to need it because they spoke
|
|
System English. The ritual then involved cutting their throats and
|
|
bleeding because their customs require returning something to the
|
|
land.
|
|
|
|
Anti-alien sentiments begin to break out and Ivanova realizes the
|
|
situation is quickly escalating out of control. Then a Narn spots a
|
|
Narn skull attached to one of the Tuchanq and fighting begins in
|
|
earnest. Ivanova is finally forced to stun the delegation with her PPG
|
|
to prevent further violence. Unfortunately the Tuchanq do not sleep,
|
|
at least not as humans understand the concept, and by making them stop
|
|
singing their songs of being and journey through the stunner, they are
|
|
now all dead (insane.)
|
|
|
|
The scene shifts back to Sheridan's office where G'Kar is imploring
|
|
Sheridan to get the Tuchanq off the station and to make ammends for
|
|
the sole death from the incident -- a Narn. Sheridan refuses his
|
|
request and G'Kar leaves in disgust.
|
|
|
|
D'Arc awakens surround by Medlab personel and quickly realizes that
|
|
her Song of Being is broken. She attacks one of the Medlab people with
|
|
a knife which she withdraws from some sort of body pouch and flees
|
|
with her Song of Journey running strong. In order to be whole again,
|
|
she would need to steal a new Song of Being from someone else.
|
|
|
|
Londo Mollari meanwhile begins trying to jockey for a chance to meet
|
|
with the Tuchanq. His conscience is still wracked with images of the
|
|
bombardment of the Narn homeworld and their destruction of their
|
|
civilization. Mollari meets up with Garibaldi who explains that the
|
|
Tuchanq are "killing" each other to cure the insanity. Once the
|
|
remaining sane Tuchanq break the Song of Journey they will be
|
|
pronounced dead and be reborn with new Songs of Being and Journey.
|
|
nu'Viel (their leader/mother) explains to Ivanova the urgency of
|
|
catching D'Arc to which Ivanova points out the size of the station and
|
|
their limited resources.
|
|
|
|
Brian Grond would become D'Arc's target. He would not realize this
|
|
yet, but his taste for peverse (See [16]Notes) sexual activities with
|
|
aliens along with his need to record them would be his downfall. Grond
|
|
was hoping to have an especially interesting encounter with Belladona
|
|
with whom he had already had several encounters. Down Below he went to
|
|
where he expected to find Belladona but she was not there. Then his
|
|
eyes met those of D'Arc. He makes an offer to give her cash if she
|
|
will take him to Belladona. D'Arc expresses her desire to murder him
|
|
with a confusing discussion of the need to take his Song of Being,
|
|
Grond merely replies yes and he heads off towards his death.
|
|
|
|
The PPG he is carrying does not save him when in the middle of a cargo
|
|
hold D'Arc pulls the knife from her pouch and kills him taking his
|
|
Song of Being. In the process, a cargo loader impacts a crane in the
|
|
cargo area leading to the possibility of the crane impacting the
|
|
station's structure and causing a rupture.
|
|
|
|
Franklin and other Medlab personnel head out to rescue the trapped
|
|
crane operator. He goes out suited up because the area has become
|
|
depressurized. Further he will have to amputate the crane operator's
|
|
leg inside the suit. The timing is close to the wire and the crane
|
|
does in fact impact the station but Franklin and the crane operator
|
|
survive, barely.
|
|
|
|
Lyta Alexander appears briefly as we see her thoughts turning to the
|
|
need to stay out of site and her desire to be able to visit the Vorlon
|
|
homeworld. Garibaldi interupts her reverie and asks for a telepathic
|
|
favor involving Tuchanq. In a moment that recalls Lyta's first role in
|
|
the pilot, she enters the Isolab to scan Tuchanq. Lyta explains that
|
|
D'Arc is like a newborn child with _no memory_ at any level of the
|
|
events that resulted in Grond's death. As Lyta leaves Medlab she
|
|
starts to hear the song, Kosh's song and realizes that nothing
|
|
separates her from the Vorlons except some empty space -- and she does
|
|
know how to deal with that.
|
|
|
|
This section of the book ends with a Gold Channel transmission from
|
|
Earth ordering Sheridan to hold D'Arc for the death penalty.
|
|
|
|
Part Two: Hunting Shadows (December 12, 2259, Night)
|
|
|
|
This section opens on Jacintha Grond's arrival at Babylon 5 customs.
|
|
(See [17]Notes). She is surprised to be greated by the ubiquitous
|
|
press specifically Debora Deverau of Channel 57 News. (See [18]Notes).
|
|
Grond is bombarded with a barrage of questions about how she feels on
|
|
a variety of issues -- "What will you do if they won't release his
|
|
body?". A security officer finally takes her hand and leads her away
|
|
from the media frenzy.
|
|
|
|
Mollari meanwhile is scheming to provide assistance to the Tuchanq.
|
|
With the help of Vir he manages to arrange a meeting with nu'Viel and
|
|
her chorus. Exploiting their hatred of the Narn, Mollari is able to
|
|
extend a credible offer of assistance.
|
|
|
|
Sheridan gets a chance to meet with Jacintha Grond who is rather
|
|
confused and upset at this point. He explains to her that he can not
|
|
release the body because it is needed for evidence and that she will
|
|
have to basically deal with the situation. She explains that she
|
|
intends to be on a return shuttle in 16 hours. Grond also takes her
|
|
anger out on Sheridan explaining that she holds him personally
|
|
responsible for the situation. Sheridan's inner frustration and
|
|
turmoil is evident but he merely invites her to remain on the station
|
|
and explains he will do the best he can.
|
|
|
|
Franklin's overuse of stims is starting to have a noticeable effect.
|
|
His first chance of sleep is interupted by the arrival of the
|
|
executioner. The executioner wants to use the life giver machine,
|
|
[19]Quality of Mercy to perform the execution and demands it from
|
|
Franklin. Franklin resists and the executioner summons Garibaldi who
|
|
seems to have been waiting for this eventuality. Garbildi recommends
|
|
that Franklin comply by providing some bits and pieces to fool the
|
|
executioner in the meanwhile.
|
|
|
|
Sheridan approaches Delenn in search of assistance and guidance. He is
|
|
disappointed to realize that Delenn has already been approached by
|
|
Earth Gov and has reluctantly agreed not to interfere. The reason she
|
|
explains has to do with her post-chrysalis state and the likelihood
|
|
that the Grey Council would overrule her.
|
|
|
|
On a core shuttle, G'Kar is attacked by Tuchanqs. G'Kar survives with
|
|
only minor injuries and a closer examination reveals that someone has
|
|
equiped humans with changling nets to make them look like Tuchanqs.
|
|
|
|
Garbaldi was already plenty busy, he had found the executioner
|
|
buldgeoned to death in the Mosque where he had gone to pray while
|
|
Franklin produced the life-giver machine. A decision is made to pay
|
|
n'Grath a visit to find out where the changling nets came from.
|
|
|
|
Garbaldi has his teams scan red sector so that he can learn where
|
|
n'Grath is to meet him. He stops in on Ivanova and they end up
|
|
fighting about the upcoming execution. Ivanova fairly clearly against
|
|
and Garbaldi somewhat indifferent to pro-execution. There attempts to
|
|
communicate are interupted by Garibaldi's comm indicating that n'Grath
|
|
has been located.
|
|
|
|
G'Kar and Vir encounter each other again and Vir is clearly still
|
|
trying to figure out how to help G'Kar and the Narns. There last
|
|
meeting had been several months back and had not gone well. G'Kar asks
|
|
Vir whether or not Mollari had him attacked and G'Kar nonetheless
|
|
hounds him further and leaves Vir feeling very uncomfortable. Vir of
|
|
course is aware that Mollari did in fact plot the attack. (See
|
|
[20]Notes.)
|
|
|
|
Vir goes and tells Londo about his meeting with G'Kar and accuses
|
|
Londo directly. Mollari refuses to answer the question, and provides
|
|
no useful information about whether or not he had G'Kar attacked.
|
|
|
|
Garibaldi arrives in Red Sector too late to for n'Grath. The creature
|
|
is bleeding and he calls for an emergency team to assist the alien.
|
|
n'Grath refuses to divulge information providing only a name "Askari"
|
|
and an admission that he did sell the nets. Garibaldi turns and
|
|
catches the motion of a gun, instead he gets a blast in his face of a
|
|
PPG. The faceplate of his suit ruptured.
|
|
|
|
G'Kar decides that he will handle Askari, a Centauri himself.
|
|
Approaching Askari he grabs him and demands to know who hired him.
|
|
Askari admits it was Mollari. G'Kar then leaves him for dead from the
|
|
dagger wound.
|
|
|
|
Violence begins to erupt on the station as protesters for and
|
|
primarily against the execution begin to start filling common areas.
|
|
Grond is starting to have a crisis about what to do and resolves to go
|
|
see D'Arc.
|
|
|
|
G'Kar comes in and attackes Mollari with his dagger. He leaves Mollari
|
|
for dead with the dagger in his back. Vir arrives and removes the
|
|
dagger and conceals it before summoning Medlab. G'Kar leaves with the
|
|
intention of committing suicide.
|
|
|
|
In Medlab, Garibaldi comes around and then Kosh shows up and
|
|
enigmatically mentions that "Obligation is a hangman's nooose.".
|
|
Meanwhile Ivanova brings nuViel to Sheridan to help lodge a protest
|
|
against the death penalty being applied to D'Arc. As they are talking
|
|
a gold channel transmission puts Sheridan in charge of everything --
|
|
trial and execution. After the transmission, nuViel decieds that
|
|
perhaps the Centauri a better choice to pursue aide from.
|
|
|
|
Part Three: Becoming Shadows (December 13, 2259, Day)
|
|
|
|
Jacintha Grond heads to security to visit D'Arc. She sees that D'Arc
|
|
is clearly suffering from brain damage based on the erratic behaviour
|
|
D'Arc is demonstrating in the holding cell. Jacintha then decided to
|
|
rent a room for the night and stay for a bit.
|
|
|
|
Vir continues to hide the dagger from security as Londo suffers in
|
|
Medlab. Franklin has to put Mollari in cryo-stasis since without
|
|
assistance of donor organs it will be impossible to save him. The idea
|
|
of using the life-giver device comes up and Vir promises to try and
|
|
seek volunteers. He discovers that none will assist Londo, they are
|
|
all afraid of him. And Centauri Prime already has a replacement
|
|
ambassador on the way. Vir also attempts to enlist the help of the
|
|
Minbari who will not assist because of religious beliefs concerning
|
|
diminshment of the soul. (Cf. [21]Soul Hunter.) Vir also thinks of
|
|
asking Kosh after he bumps into him, but decides against it after
|
|
getting a sense of someone walking over his grave when talking.
|
|
|
|
Sheridan will not agree to Franklin's request to order people to
|
|
donate life energy but agrees to assist in broadcasting a request for
|
|
assistance on the station network.
|
|
|
|
G'Kar was still alive because without his dagger he could not perform
|
|
suicide. Sheridan visits G'Kar and G'Kar shows him a different dagger
|
|
thus "tricking" Sheridan into thinking he didn't do it. Vir returns
|
|
the dagger to G'Kar later saying "I said I was sorry."
|
|
|
|
Garibaldi starts getting the sense of the violence that is going to
|
|
break out on the station on his way through the station that day.
|
|
Protesters are all around with signs pleading to save the alien.
|
|
Garibaldi true to form uses his fists to break up a fight and is
|
|
caught in the act on camera by Devereau from Channel 57. Morden
|
|
happens to be on hand and gets interviewed as the guy on the street.
|
|
He says, "I suppose that all life is important in some way." Then as
|
|
if nodding to himself, he continues, "Yes. That's what I believe. Life
|
|
is important. If you know what to do with it."
|
|
|
|
Morden then continues to talk with Garibaldi and asks him about
|
|
assisting in saving Mollari. Garibaldi rebuffs the suggestion pointing
|
|
out he would die. Morden remains silent. Morden then shrugs and says
|
|
"Then I'll consider the debt yet to be repaid." Smiling, he says,
|
|
"Join me on the monorail?" Garibaldi is interupted by Sheridan on the
|
|
comm link and takes his leave of Morden.
|
|
|
|
The court chamber. Grond is looking on as the trial commences.
|
|
Sheridan takes his place as judge, there will be no jury. nuViel is
|
|
used as a witness for the prosecution to explain that D'Arc had
|
|
murdered before. Sheridan responded to prosecution demands that nuViel
|
|
restrict her answers to the questions, cutting her off regularly. (See
|
|
[22]Notes.) On cross-examination, the defense tries to bring out the
|
|
issues about D'Arc's psychosis which seems to fall on deaf ears. The
|
|
defense calls Dr. Franklin to the stand for direct who explains about
|
|
the brain damage and her child like state. (See [23]Notes.) Sheridan
|
|
recesses and on return finds D'Arc guilty on murder. As if on cue
|
|
chaos breaks out in the court room. Grond even agrees saying on TV
|
|
that she feels justice is not served.
|
|
|
|
In Medlab, Sheridan tries to get Franklin to agree to sedate D'Arc. He
|
|
balks and Sheridan begins to administer the hypo and Franklin agrees
|
|
to do it only to prevent Sheridan from killing her by giving the hypo.
|
|
|
|
Garibaldi notices Morden leaving Medlab and that he has used the
|
|
life-giver without the assistance of any others to save Londo.
|
|
Garibaldi also realizes that the Shadows had a hand since otherwise
|
|
Morden would be dead.
|
|
|
|
G'Kar can't bring himself to go through with the suicide because of
|
|
his fear of what the future holds. He leaves his quarters to go out
|
|
and shape the future.
|
|
|
|
Jacintha Grond goes to find her husband and sees he is missing. The
|
|
station is descending into further chaos as the preparations for the
|
|
execution procession commence. The execution will be in an airlock.
|
|
Devereau grills Sheridan why such barbarism is being used to execute
|
|
D'Arc and why there are crowds, etc. Then G'Kar arrived to beg
|
|
forgiveness from nuViel. She grants him forgiveness. Then, all hell
|
|
breaks loose.
|
|
|
|
Even Devereau had never seen violence like this. She managed to don a
|
|
gas mask to aide herself. After enough of the violent protesters were
|
|
downed with gas, the procession proceded towards an airlock. Franklin
|
|
makes one last attempt to block the airlock with his body. Delenn
|
|
offers a very insightful comment stating:
|
|
|
|
This event has left in my mind an extraordinary feeling of terror
|
|
and shame. It seems to me I have been witness to -- and indeed,
|
|
party to -- an act of ... of shameful violence perpetrated by
|
|
intelligent beings [glance to Sheridan] against one of their
|
|
fellows. No matter what anyone might say, violence will never
|
|
prevent violence.
|
|
|
|
After the death, a gold channel message comes in while they are all
|
|
near the airlock. Sheridan allows it to be played there. No clemancy
|
|
from the Senate, either way it was too late.
|
|
|
|
257 Wounded. 53 Deaths, including a miscarried pregnancy.
|
|
|
|
Clark calls Sheridan to thank him. Sheridan is feeling sick on the
|
|
inside.
|
|
|
|
Ivanova helps the Tuchanq delegation head off the station. The Tuchanq
|
|
have accepted the Centauri offer.
|
|
|
|
Franklin and Garibaldi arrive together. Franklin is stating he wants
|
|
to lodge a complaint. Sheridan deters him by explaining that Garibaldi
|
|
and he had swapped the bodies, D'Arc is safe and actually Brian Grond
|
|
who was already dead -- wearing a changling net -- was executed.
|
|
|
|
The book ends with some words from Kosh. Kosh looks at him quietly.
|
|
Like a mirror. Fear is a mirror. Sheridan speaks, "I understand now.
|
|
Because I was scared I became devious. I took advantage of people and
|
|
events to accomplish my own ends... ...my fear has enabled me to
|
|
understand myself more clearly." Finally, Kosh said, "You are the
|
|
light, yet the hope of all darkness." Pause. "You are touched by
|
|
Shadows." Then Kosh leaves. The book ends with Sheridan realizing in a
|
|
moment of truth that his life would end as it had begun with awe and
|
|
wonder, pain and terror. And Shadows, always with Shadows.
|
|
|
|
Epilogue: Truth
|
|
|
|
"Earth: The First Truth": We see Clark contemplating the future in the
|
|
Senate Chamber in late December 2259. He realizes that the actions he
|
|
takes today will cause him not only to be remembered by the future but
|
|
to define it. A quote next to the page explains how EarthGov has
|
|
subpeonaed the footage from the execution to avoid scandal. Deverau
|
|
(the anchor) also mentions that the death penalty has now been
|
|
repealed to avoid scandal.
|
|
|
|
"Tuchanq: The Second Truth": nuViel stands surveying the planet now
|
|
that Tunchanq is being "aided" by the Centauri. She realizes that in
|
|
reality the Tuchanq song now belongs to the Shadows.
|
|
|
|
"The Rim: The Final Truth": Captain Varese finds his ship under
|
|
assault by screaming ships. As he dies, he has a peculiar sense of
|
|
deja vu about his final words, "They fired first."
|
|
|
|
The book ends: 2259:
|
|
|
|
It was Christmas Eve, 2259: the dawn of the Third Age of Mankind.
|
|
The Shadows were coming.
|
|
|
|
Unanswered Questions
|
|
|
|
* What's the deal with singing and songs? The issue has been brought
|
|
up several times in relation to the Vorlons and now with the
|
|
Tuchanq. What relation is there if any to the way the machine on
|
|
Epsilon 3 functions especially given some of the descriptions in
|
|
this book about how the songs serve as a connection to the land
|
|
(place)?
|
|
* Is Kosh's comment to the recovering Garibaldi prophetic in terms
|
|
of predicting the run in with Morden or meant to be prophetic in
|
|
the longer term?
|
|
* Are we to assume that Morden was prompted by the shadows when
|
|
giving his speech to Devereau? And if so, how are we to take it in
|
|
terms of what the future would hold should the Shadows gain
|
|
ground?
|
|
* What is Kosh up to with Sheridan? As the ending dialog suggests,
|
|
whatever is going on is a lot more complicated than simply
|
|
teaching Sheridan. Perhaps there is a special role for Sheridan
|
|
much like Sinclair had a special role for the Minbari and Humans.
|
|
|
|
Analysis
|
|
|
|
* The parallels between what the Narn did to the Tuchanq and what
|
|
the Centauri did to the Narn are extremely striking.
|
|
* This particular novel fits with the overall storyline much tighter
|
|
than others. The insights we gain on the fragile hold of Clark on
|
|
power as well as his willingness to use deception and trickery to
|
|
gain popularity are telling about other story arc elements such as
|
|
the Night Watch.
|
|
* Things are moving quickly. This corresponds with the increased
|
|
pace of the show, Earth, Babylon 5, and the universe are getting
|
|
ready for a big explosion.
|
|
|
|
Notes
|
|
|
|
* The second lie portion of the prologue should probably be dated
|
|
October of 2259 not 2258. This is an editting error in all
|
|
likelyhood. The reason it is an error is that Clark did not become
|
|
president until the very end of Season 1, which took all of 2258
|
|
and further a death penalty law would not go a full year without a
|
|
test. Also the Tuchanq second lie is, we presume, supposed to
|
|
occur shortly after the re-enactment of the death penalty.
|
|
* This book has extremely detailed albiet sometimes apparently
|
|
inaccurate descriptions of the station -- Ivanova's quarters --
|
|
but it does give a nice sense of the station.
|
|
* Another editing error seems to involve the captain's name in the
|
|
prologue and the epilogue both should presumably be the same since
|
|
presumably the deja vu has do with previously having said "They
|
|
fired first."
|
|
* It is surprising that G'Kar and perhaps Narns in general have such
|
|
difficulty grasping human subtlety. Contrast this with the
|
|
generally broder understanding demonstrated by the Minbari and
|
|
Vorlons at reading between the lines, etc. This may have more to
|
|
do with experience and knowledge due to general species age than
|
|
anything else. Alternatively it can be indicative of why the Narn
|
|
(and Centauri) are dying species.
|
|
* It is interesting to note that there seem to be taboos against
|
|
miscegenation with alien races much like we had enforced by law in
|
|
the United States and still now by prejudice in some areas. [See:
|
|
bans on interracial mariages unconstitutional, Loving v Virginia
|
|
(U.S. Supreme Court 1967) and compare with the 1984 custody case
|
|
involving Mrs. Palmore's daughter which reached the Supreme Court
|
|
because of Mrs. Palmore's subsequent interracial marriage. Palmore
|
|
v. Sidoti, (U.S. Supreme Court 1984)].
|
|
* Lyta's appearance is extremely well done and helps tie together
|
|
her appearance in relation to Talia and then her later appearance
|
|
back on the station after visiting the Vorlons.
|
|
* Timing of the sections seems to be slightly problematic since it
|
|
seems a bit unlikely that Jacintha Grond could get from Mars to
|
|
Babylon 5 _so_ quickly, less than a day.
|
|
* I believe Devereau has been seen before, except she had worked for
|
|
ISN, perhaps this is a change of jobs or just an editting error.
|
|
* I take the references on p 141, par 3-4, to indicate Mollari
|
|
ordered the attack on G'Kar and that Vir strongly suspected that
|
|
it was true, this may be an incorrect inference.
|
|
* From the trial scene it is interesting to note that little has
|
|
changed in the basic procedure of the Common Law system of trial
|
|
and justice.
|
|
* In the United States today, the death penalty has and continues to
|
|
be carried out on the mentally retarded, even upon people with
|
|
IQ's as low as 60. (McCollum v. No. Carolina, US SC 1994:
|
|
Blackmun's dissent from the denial of review mentions that the
|
|
person to be executed has a 9 yr old mental age and can barely
|
|
read at a second grade level. He was "under stress and easily
|
|
influenced by others." Continuing, Blackmun explains how the lower
|
|
court found:
|
|
|
|
that he committed the felony murder under the influence of mental
|
|
or emotional disturbance, that he had cooperated with the police,
|
|
that he had no significant history of prior criminal activity, and
|
|
that he had adapted well to prison. In addition, the trial judge
|
|
concluded that "[a]ll of the evidence tends to show that
|
|
[McCollum's] capacity ... to appreciate the criminality of his
|
|
conduct or to conform to the requirements of law was impaired."
|
|
McCollum was 19 at the time of the crime.
|
|
Blackmun's dissent concludes on a note that is similar to the
|
|
rationale that the senate used in turning down the death penalty:
|
|
"Our system of capital punishment simply does not accurately and
|
|
consistently determine which defendants most "deserve" to die."
|
|
The sole standard that the Supreme Court has established is that
|
|
at the time of death the person must be able to comprehend what is
|
|
going to happen to them thus leading to ironies like lawyers
|
|
trying to have their clients taken off anti-psychotic drugs to
|
|
prevent executions.
|
|
|
|
jms speaks
|
|
|
|
* _Will D'Arc appear in the show?_
|
|
Probably not, but one never knows.
|
|
* _Lyta is deaf?_
|
|
I don't know how that would've gotten past me...I don't recall
|
|
seeing that in the draft...either I was tired when reading, or it
|
|
was added later.
|
|
* No, the novelist didn't blow it, Joe blew it, because in
|
|
proofreading the manuscript, Joe missed that line somehow, and
|
|
didn't catch it. It's my job to catch these things. (Just spent a
|
|
whole week going over the A-Z of Babylon 5 coming out from Boxtree
|
|
Books in the UK to keep it as accuate as possible.)
|
|
* _Why did the captain lie?_
|
|
The Minbari approached with their gun ports opened...but they also
|
|
hadn't locked on. They were a potential menace, but had not gone
|
|
into the territory of definite menace...and when they fired, it
|
|
was clear from the moment or two it took to respond that the
|
|
Minbari ships weren't ready to attack. So he chose to cover his
|
|
butt rather than take responsibility for screwing up a first
|
|
contact situation and plunging Earth into a war.
|
|
|
|
|
|
_________________________________________________________________
|
|
|
|
Written by Erik Oliver <[24]oliver@dolphin.upenn.edu>.
|
|
|
|
[30][Next]
|
|
|
|
Last update: January 15, 1997
|
|
|
|
References
|
|
|
|
1. file://localhost/cgi-bin/imagemap/titlebar
|
|
2. LYNXIMGMAP:file://localhost/lurk/maps/maps.html#titlebar
|
|
3. file://localhost/lurk/gif/novels/004.jpg
|
|
4. file://localhost/home/woodstock/hyperion/docs/lurk/novels/index.html
|
|
5. file://localhost/home/woodstock/hyperion/docs/lurk/novels/003.html
|
|
6. file://localhost/home/woodstock/hyperion/docs/lurk/novels/005.html
|
|
7. file://localhost/home/woodstock/hyperion/docs/lurk/novels/004.html#BC
|
|
8. file://localhost/home/woodstock/hyperion/docs/lurk/novels/004.html#SY
|
|
9. file://localhost/home/woodstock/hyperion/docs/lurk/novels/004.html#UQ
|
|
10. file://localhost/home/woodstock/hyperion/docs/lurk/novels/004.html#AN
|
|
11. file://localhost/home/woodstock/hyperion/docs/lurk/novels/004.html#NO
|
|
12. file://localhost/home/woodstock/hyperion/docs/lurk/novels/004.html#JS
|
|
13. file://localhost/lurk/guide/043.html
|
|
14. file://localhost/lurk/guide/044.html
|
|
15. file://localhost/home/woodstock/hyperion/docs/lurk/novels/004.html#NO
|
|
16. file://localhost/home/woodstock/hyperion/docs/lurk/novels/004.html#NO
|
|
17. file://localhost/home/woodstock/hyperion/docs/lurk/novels/004.html#NO
|
|
18. file://localhost/home/woodstock/hyperion/docs/lurk/novels/004.html#NO
|
|
19. file://localhost/lurk/guide/021.html
|
|
20. file://localhost/home/woodstock/hyperion/docs/lurk/novels/004.html#NO
|
|
21. file://localhost/lurk/guide/002.html
|
|
22. file://localhost/home/woodstock/hyperion/docs/lurk/novels/004.html#NO
|
|
23. file://localhost/home/woodstock/hyperion/docs/lurk/novels/no
|
|
24. mailto:oliver@dolphin.upenn.edu
|
|
25. file://localhost/lurk/lurker.html
|
|
26. file://localhost/home/woodstock/hyperion/docs/lurk/novels/004.html#TOP
|
|
27. file://localhost/cgi-bin/uncgi/lgmail
|
|
28. file://localhost/home/woodstock/hyperion/docs/lurk/episodes.php
|
|
29. file://localhost/home/woodstock/hyperion/docs/lurk/novels/003.html
|
|
30. file://localhost/home/woodstock/hyperion/docs/lurk/novels/005.html
|